skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

We've been here before for pizza and wings, which were good. Tonight was chicken parmesan and eggplant parmesan and WOW both were great.
Christopher Billings via google.com - Sep 11, 2021
Garlic knots are great.
Roy via google.com - Sep 1, 2021
Great food, staff needs help with customer service ... read more
john belcher via google.com - Aug 31, 2021
Amazing! I am from NJ and the pizza was definitely on par with NY/NJ tri-state area pizza. I also had the meatballs with ricotta. I said that I think that someone was hiding in my kitchen writing down my recipe. Will be returning.
Mary Jane Ellis via google.com - Aug 7, 2021
Awesome food good price ... read more
Keith Jennings via google.com - Aug 1, 2021
Great pizza, even better wings! Garlic knots are amazing!
Josep Rivera via google.com - Jul 22, 2021
Great pizza ... read more
Amanda Smith via google.com - Jul 17, 2021
BEST WINGS IN JAX!!! really, though. its the only place ill eat wings. The new owner Dave has really turned this place around!!
Evan Kay via google.com - Jul 16, 2021
The food is consistently good! Pizza is good as well. I'm looking forward to the new menu and specials.
robert leviton via google.com - Jul 16, 2021
This some best pizza Caleb best server lace clean place ... read more
Gina Franco via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
Great Dinner tonight. The food was great, we ended up having garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, poutine, pizza, wings and some to go boxes. We also had some homemade cake and cannolis to go. Special shout out to Caleb, thank you for the awesome service! Great Spot for some food. Also their marinara is outstanding, bright and flav ... read more
Chris Barrett via google.com - Jun 23, 2021
Ordered there for the first time. Calzone and stromboli were awesome. We will definitely be going back.
Debbie Swihart via google.com - Jun 21, 2021
Awesome pizza friendly environment ... read more
Ramon Villafane via google.com - May 17, 2021
Great experience and food was better than ever. The new owner is working hard to improve the existi
Great experience and food was better than ever. The new owner is working hard to improve the existing items and add new items.
Kevin Noffsinger via facebook.com - Apr 27, 2021
The food is very Authentic tasty. The wings are big, Juicy, and very flavored. The pizza is exclusive from the taste, texture, and the quality of the ingredients are unmatched. That dough is freshly made and is instantly noticable. Customer service was just as genuine as the ingredients in the food. Caleb was the man. Friendly and kn ... read more
Sidney Johnson via google.com - Apr 26, 2021
Cheese pizza with garlic is what I get on cheat day ... read more
Joseph Moore via google.com - Apr 20, 2021
We were a bit hesitant at first as we know it changed hands back around January 2021 or so, but we a
We were a bit hesitant at first as we know it changed hands back around January 2021 or so, but we are delighted to say it was very very good and "Caleb", our server was great, too!
56brucea via tripadvisor.com - Apr 17, 2021
It was good ... read more
Michele Hoover via google.com - Apr 14, 2021
Great staff and owner we had a custom specialty pizza and loved every slice we will be back for more pickle pizza ... read more
Julio Martinez Jr. via google.com - Apr 5, 2021
Best pizza! Friendly service! Clean, relaxed atmosphere! My son brings my grandchildren up from
Best pizza! Friendly service! Clean, relaxed atmosphere! My son brings my grandchildren up from St. Augustine for their pizza and their meatballs!
Cynthia Doyle via facebook.com - Apr 3, 2021
The pizza, service, and beer choices are A-1. Specifically, in regards to the pizza, it's so good that it's hard to even see myself ordering from anywhere else. Plus they are a business that is invested in the Oakleaf community. As a resident of Oakleaf that matters to me.
offdacorner via google.com - Mar 17, 2021
Good NY style pizza. oregano overload on the meatballs ... read more
Robin Pierce via google.com - Mar 16, 2021
Little bit of a wait for a curbside pickup, on a busy Friday night, but the wait was worth it, because every bite of food was hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. I will definitely be back to continue sampling the menu. NY style pizza was great, the dough is delicious. Garlic knots are outta the park! Fried ravioli would be better i ... read more
Devon N via google.com - Mar 13, 2021
Awesome wings and pizza. Service is great too.
David Parks via google.com - Mar 12, 2021
Fantastic wings and pizza! But eating it there is so much better than if you have a long way to go
Fantastic wings and pizza! But eating it there is so much better than if you have a long way to go home! Also the lasagna is the best ever. They give huge portions so plan on a to-go box! New owner will always be sure to make your experience great ... read more
Laura Davis via facebook.com - Mar 4, 2021
This is the best pizza available in a 20 mile radius. The dough is the best if you are a pizza person. Quality ingredients and the gravy (sauce) is fresh and flavorful. The meatballs are better than grandma's. Plus they have a great selection of beer. King Street is on tap!
Bryan Meyers via google.com - Feb 19, 2021
Great service and I like how they salute the military and America .
Gregory Johns via google.com - Feb 19, 2021
Me encanta la lasaña ... read more
CAROLINA CUMARE via google.com - Feb 19, 2021
We love their pizza and pass several pizza places on our 15 mile journey there. However today we decided to try their chicken wings. They were big, juicy and delicious. The wings at our go to wing place have gotten smaller over the last year. This will be our new wing place ... read more
Stephen Hancock via google.com - Feb 19, 2021
Great pizza great service.
matthew luna via google.com - Feb 19, 2021
Best wings ever! I know people have complained but, get over it when having delivered. I get the same every time and never complained. Pepperoni mushroom pizza and 10 breaded wings sauce on the side. 10 years no problems!!
doug johnson via google.com - Feb 19, 2021
First time here. Loved it!!
Jennifer Kelm via google.com - Jan 19, 2021
I'm supporting Small Business in such difficult times... If you love New York Pizza 🍕 you must try NYC Meatballs Pizzeria, they make some good Pizza just like in New York... I really recommend their Pizza Il be back for more...
Boricua via google.com - Jan 19, 2021
We have eaten here several times and have enjoyed the food. We order the deluxe pizza and it always hits the spot! Great food and service.
Rebecca Cullen via google.com - Jan 19, 2021
Great pizza, usually busy on Fridays and Saturdays. Call early ... read more
Walter Smith via google.com - Jan 19, 2021
A NY native- this pizza is seriously the best pizza I’ve had outside of the tri state area! It’s keeping me from missing home and saving my craving!
Jaime Donnelly via google.com - Jan 19, 2021
Great atmosphere with TVs, bar, and large menu selection. Excellent service and great price for quan
Great atmosphere with TVs, bar, and large menu selection. Excellent service and great price for quantity and quality! We will be back. It's close to Oakleaf Shopping and great place to bring our family.
alsapp via tripadvisor.com - Jan 9, 2021
Honestly, never had a bad pizza in 3 years of eating here. I would say probably top 2 in the Jackson
Honestly, never had a bad pizza in 3 years of eating here. I would say probably top 2 in the Jacksonville area. Their wings are really good too. Happy hour and 1/2 domestic beer specials are pretty solid. I personally would like to see the microbrews go on special.
782kevins via tripadvisor.com - Dec 31, 2020
Great atmosphere, Great Service & Ahhhmazing pizza!
Melissa Latronica via google.com - Dec 19, 2020
Super good after walking 6 miles ... read more
Alyce Willis via google.com - Dec 19, 2020
A good pizza place is hard to find. A great one is a rarity. I went here because my first choice seems to have gone out of business, but this was truly a happy discovery. I had a salad and pizza. The salad was one of the better ones I've gotten from a restaurant. Crisp , and most importantly DRY. Also very tasty. The pizza was truly ... read more
Paul Nebeling via google.com - Dec 19, 2020
Great as usual!!!
Grady Sims via google.com - Nov 19, 2020
Awesome pizza and great atmosphere!!!
Danny Shaffer via google.com - Nov 19, 2020
Been going here for a good while now. The owner is a great person. Staff are always friendly and professional. The food...whew I could LIVE off of that pizza alone, but the PATRIOTISM?! Sign me up, I’ll always choose NYC Pizza!
Zach Littlejohn via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Food and service is great and now that’s he’s redecorated and taken a stand against the disrespect of America I Love the place even more. Owner loves his Community, LEO, Military, First Responders and America. Go eat and have a good time just don’t expect to see Whiny Professional sports that disrespect this country played on the T ... read more
Kevin Hanning via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Food always good finally have gluten free option for a larger pizza. Love this place but miss the artwork ... read more
Matt Quant via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Great food.
trisha smith via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Great pizza, fantastic wings and a family friendly atmosphere! This place does not disappoint!!
Alyssa Wallace via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Always great, the Garlic Parm Wings are excellent!
Thomas Robinson via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
I met up with several people here tonight. It was my first visit. I had a yummy calzone and took home cannoli. The cannoli was excellent as well. The prices were reasonable. I enjoyed the patriotic decor.
Brenda- Vasquez Values via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire