skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

A++
Good meal and exceptional service. Caleb, our server, was extremely personal and enhanced our dining experience with his friendly smile.
ilv2trvl2 via tripadvisor.com - Jan 15, 2022
Great pizza and wings. Staff was super nice and helpful.
Bob Ward via google.com - Jan 10, 2022
Excellent!! Best Veggie Pizza ever!
C Wten via google.com - Jan 3, 2022
My server was awesome! This time, I got the Pepperoni and Sausage Stromboli and it was great! I highly recommend it, as well as, the garlic knots!
T. Gerard Robinson via google.com - Jan 2, 2022
Great pizza with great service!
andyisarobot 3 via google.com - Dec 5, 2021
Local neighborhood pizza spot! If its wrong they fix it! The pizza is great! I love the ease of use
Local neighborhood pizza spot! If its wrong they fix it! The pizza is great! I love the ease of use on the app!
Jessica J. via yelp.com - Dec 5, 2021
I really like this places pizza and wings. Their breaded sweet thai chili wings are really good. How
I really like this places pizza and wings. Their breaded sweet thai chili wings are really good. However, I do have a couple of complaints. Every time I call it is hard to get them to take my order in a timely manner. For today's order, the left a topping off of my pizza after I waited close to an hour and a half for a delivery.
Brad H. via yelp.com - Dec 4, 2021
Best Pizza in Oakleaf ... read more
Chris B via google.com - Nov 12, 2021
Ordered half pepperoni half pineapple and pepperoni pizza it was sooo delicious!! Great service, great atmosphere will definitely come again!!
TARA Coston via google.com - Nov 12, 2021
Best cauliflower pizza in Jacksonville!
Will Petrelli via google.com - Nov 7, 2021
Ordered a few times now and the pizza and garlic knots are fantastic. Recommend ordering extra cheese because it can be pretty light on the cheese compared to other places. My kids love cheese pizzas from here. No delivery even though I live in the same neighborhood kind of stinks but it's worth picking it up. Way better than regular ... read more
Steven Anderson via google.com - Nov 5, 2021
First time getting food since the newest owner. Wings were huge, cooked perfect and were done right on time. Friendly staff.
Art Pimental via google.com - Oct 20, 2021
We got the pickle pizza, fried ravioli and 2 different kinds of wings. The food was absolutely amazing and our waiter was great. He was super busy, but got us everything we needed and was on top of it. Thanks for an awesome dining experience.
viperdog92 via google.com - Oct 9, 2021
Great pizza ... read more
Maryanne Markowski via google.com - Oct 3, 2021
First time going here was last Sunday and man I've been missing out. Garlic knots were out of the park, their cajun ranch wings were somehow the best wings I've ever had and coming from a pizza place? Shocker! And then the pizza.... that was great too. Classic ny style and the crust was crispy. Not to mention everything was fresh and ... read more
Logan S via google.com - Sep 29, 2021
We've been here before for pizza and wings, which were good. Tonight was chicken parmesan and eggplant parmesan and WOW both were great.
Christopher Billings via google.com - Sep 11, 2021
Garlic knots are great.
Roy via google.com - Sep 1, 2021
Great food, staff needs help with customer service ... read more
john belcher via google.com - Aug 31, 2021
Stromboli, calzone, and lasagna is top-notch! Definitely worth going a bit out of your way.
Stromboli, calzone, and lasagna is top-notch! Definitely worth going a bit out of your way.
Susan H. via yelp.com - Aug 16, 2021
I really like this place. Ethan the server is awesome!!! Pizza is good, wings are good, and so is th
I really like this place. Ethan the server is awesome!!! Pizza is good, wings are good, and so is the fried ravioli. If they offered a full bar... I'd give 5 stars!!! I'll always revisit ... read more
Cee L. via yelp.com - Aug 14, 2021
Amazing! I am from NJ and the pizza was definitely on par with NY/NJ tri-state area pizza. I also had the meatballs with ricotta. I said that I think that someone was hiding in my kitchen writing down my recipe. Will be returning.
Mary Jane Ellis via google.com - Aug 7, 2021
Awesome food good price ... read more
Keith Jennings via google.com - Aug 1, 2021
Great pizza, even better wings! Garlic knots are amazing!
Josep Rivera via google.com - Jul 22, 2021
Great pizza ... read more
Amanda Smith via google.com - Jul 17, 2021
BEST WINGS IN JAX!!! really, though. its the only place ill eat wings. The new owner Dave has really turned this place around!!
Evan Kay via google.com - Jul 16, 2021
The food is consistently good! Pizza is good as well. I'm looking forward to the new menu and specials.
robert leviton via google.com - Jul 16, 2021
Pretty good local place. Can't give 5 stars because sometimes when we go the wings are soggier than
Pretty good local place. Can't give 5 stars because sometimes when we go the wings are soggier than usual or the pizza isn't done at the same consistently. The server there usually does a great job trying to juggle as many tables as he has, and they always have cold delicious craft beer on tap which is perfect. My husband loves their ... read more
Emily K. via yelp.com - Jul 1, 2021
This some best pizza Caleb best server lace clean place ... read more
Gina Franco via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
This pizza is so good Caleb the server was so great place is so clean. I would come here again.
This pizza is so good Caleb the server was so great place is so clean. I would come here again.
Gina F. via yelp.com - Jun 26, 2021
Great Dinner tonight. The food was great, we ended up having garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, poutine, pizza, wings and some to go boxes. We also had some homemade cake and cannolis to go. Special shout out to Caleb, thank you for the awesome service! Great Spot for some food. Also their marinara is outstanding, bright and flav ... read more
Chris Barrett via google.com - Jun 23, 2021
Ordered there for the first time. Calzone and stromboli were awesome. We will definitely be going back.
Debbie Swihart via google.com - Jun 21, 2021
So good!!!! Chicken Parm is the best!!! Bite size pieces of chicken perfectly fried over spaghetti &
So good!!!! Chicken Parm is the best!!! Bite size pieces of chicken perfectly fried over spaghetti & topped with mozzarella. What also makes this dish so outstanding is their sauce! Their pizza is also so NY & so damn delicious!
Mary B. via yelp.com - Jun 14, 2021
First time there and it was amazing! The food was great! Fresh wings and they are HUGE! The pizza wa
First time there and it was amazing! The food was great! Fresh wings and they are HUGE! The pizza was really good too. Garlic knots are everything! Officially my new fav pizza place. And the reviews were right, the Cajun ranch wings are BOMB!
Jae D. via yelp.com - Jun 7, 2021
This is our go to for pizza and wings every Friday. They have not disappointed at any time. Delivery
This is our go to for pizza and wings every Friday. They have not disappointed at any time. Delivery persons are great as well.
Reggie H. via yelp.com - Jun 4, 2021
Awesome pizza friendly environment ... read more
Ramon Villafane via google.com - May 17, 2021
I want to start by saying NYC Meatballs and pizza is one of my favorite pizza restaurants. Compared
I want to start by saying NYC Meatballs and pizza is one of my favorite pizza restaurants. Compared to Chicago, I would give this restaurant a 7 out of 10. Customer service is not really great. Most of the young ladies who work there are not that friendly. They have a way of making me feel like I'm not welcome. No smiles, barely even ... read more
Jay C. via yelp.com - May 11, 2021
Get on in and get some of the best wings in Jax from this little gem hidden out in Oakleaf. Great pi
Get on in and get some of the best wings in Jax from this little gem hidden out in Oakleaf. Great pizza, salads and wings. Awesome staff every time! Even when they are slammed on The weekends it's worth the wait and the food is always worth it!
Brian W. via yelp.com - May 3, 2021
Great experience and food was better than ever. The new owner is working hard to improve the existi
Great experience and food was better than ever. The new owner is working hard to improve the existing items and add new items.
Kevin Noffsinger via facebook.com - Apr 27, 2021
The food is very Authentic tasty. The wings are big, Juicy, and very flavored. The pizza is exclusive from the taste, texture, and the quality of the ingredients are unmatched. That dough is freshly made and is instantly noticable. Customer service was just as genuine as the ingredients in the food. Caleb was the man. Friendly and kn ... read more
Sidney Johnson via google.com - Apr 26, 2021
Cheese pizza with garlic is what I get on cheat day ... read more
Joseph Moore via google.com - Apr 20, 2021
We were a bit hesitant at first as we know it changed hands back around January 2021 or so, but we a
We were a bit hesitant at first as we know it changed hands back around January 2021 or so, but we are delighted to say it was very very good and "Caleb", our server was great, too!
56brucea via tripadvisor.com - Apr 17, 2021
It was good ... read more
Michele Hoover via google.com - Apr 14, 2021
Great staff and owner we had a custom specialty pizza and loved every slice we will be back for more pickle pizza ... read more
Julio Martinez Jr. via google.com - Apr 5, 2021
Best pizza! Friendly service! Clean, relaxed atmosphere! My son brings my grandchildren up from
Best pizza! Friendly service! Clean, relaxed atmosphere! My son brings my grandchildren up from St. Augustine for their pizza and their meatballs!
Cynthia Doyle via facebook.com - Apr 3, 2021
The pizza, service, and beer choices are A-1. Specifically, in regards to the pizza, it's so good that it's hard to even see myself ordering from anywhere else. Plus they are a business that is invested in the Oakleaf community. As a resident of Oakleaf that matters to me.
offdacorner via google.com - Mar 17, 2021
Good NY style pizza. oregano overload on the meatballs ... read more
Robin Pierce via google.com - Mar 16, 2021
Little bit of a wait for a curbside pickup, on a busy Friday night, but the wait was worth it, because every bite of food was hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. I will definitely be back to continue sampling the menu. NY style pizza was great, the dough is delicious. Garlic knots are outta the park! Fried ravioli would be better i ... read more
Devon N via google.com - Mar 13, 2021
Awesome wings and pizza. Service is great too.
David Parks via google.com - Mar 12, 2021
NYC Meatballs is 5 star. Spotlessly clean, great beer selection on tap. Great service from the young
NYC Meatballs is 5 star. Spotlessly clean, great beer selection on tap. Great service from the young man that helped us this past Thursday late afternoon. We had the Poutine, a large serving of some great fries topped w a nice gravy and melted cheese curds. Delicious. Next the warm Ricotta topped homeade (with the perfect texture and ... read more
Chris C. via yelp.com - Mar 12, 2021
Fantastic wings and pizza! But eating it there is so much better than if you have a long way to go
Fantastic wings and pizza! But eating it there is so much better than if you have a long way to go home! Also the lasagna is the best ever. They give huge portions so plan on a to-go box! New owner will always be sure to make your experience great ... read more
Laura Davis via facebook.com - Mar 4, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire