skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Love the stromboli. The kids like the wings, and the pizza with extra cheese Will be going back for the meatballs!
Linda Fetrow via google.com - May 19, 2022
The cauliflower pizza was very good.
Jennifer Atchison via google.com - May 18, 2022
The pizza is good. We always order at 8 pm because of the pizza special Sun through Thur. The garlic knots are super oily and that’s why we don’t order them anymore but the pizza and calzone are pretty good.
Eve Lebron via google.com - May 11, 2022
Ordered for the first time tonight and it was AWESOME! Pizza was ready on time when I got there, th
Ordered for the first time tonight and it was AWESOME! Pizza was ready on time when I got there, the girl working was really nice and food was great. After having a poor experience with another pizza place nearby, this made our night. Price was also very reasonable. Will definitely be repeat customers!
Carly Dattilo via facebook.com - May 7, 2022
Ordered for the first time tonight and it was AWESOME! Pizza was ready on time when I got there, the girl working was really nice and food was great. After having a poor experience with another pizza place nearby, this made our night. Price was also very reasonable. Will definitely be repeat customers!
Carly Caudill via google.com - May 6, 2022
Went for the first time on Saturday ordered 18" deluxe with a order of Garlic Knots. Employees were very nice and helpful, both items were very good. Can't wait to go back.
cappy3750 via google.com - May 2, 2022
Quaint atmosphere, wide variety of beers. Definitely worth a visit.
Keith Jefferson via google.com - Apr 29, 2022
Everytime I've visited, the food and service were on point. Pizzas are delicious; haven't had a bad one yet! Garlic knots are really good, too. My recent visit I tried the lasagna. Great choice. Huge portion, cheesy, flavorful and came with two garlic bread slices. It's hard to find good lasagna without having to visit an expensive I ... read more
Alex Navarro via google.com - Apr 23, 2022
My 12 yr old daughter & I LOVE thier chicken Alfredo pizza!! The best around! I do like thier fried pickle spears!! And when they offered fried cheese triangles vice sticks!!
Shawn Lachance via google.com - Apr 17, 2022
Great pizza's and wing's!!! My Go-to every time I am here and want pizza!! Quick service!!
Great pizza's and wing's!!! My Go-to every time I am here and want pizza!! Quick service!!
Andrew A. via yelp.com - Mar 23, 2022
So I haven't been to NYC Meatballs in years since I moved away from Orange Park, plus I heard they h
So I haven't been to NYC Meatballs in years since I moved away from Orange Park, plus I heard they had new ownership, so I happy to see that they were on the list of events for the Yelp Elite Squad. I was lucky enough to see a fellow Yelper and her mom there and even had a nice conversation with Mr. Dave the Owner. The Pizza Slices w ... read more
Richard H. via yelp.com - Mar 15, 2022
First timers…visited for dinner on a Sunday evening. Anthony was our server and he provided top notch service and had a great personality. He was also very knowledgeable of the menu, kept drinks full, and checked on us periodically. The food was delicious, garlic knots are AMAZING! Everyone ordered something different and we all like ... read more
Niecy via google.com - Mar 14, 2022
Went as part of the Yelp event and everything was soooo good. The garlic knots were cooked perfectly
Went as part of the Yelp event and everything was soooo good. The garlic knots were cooked perfectly. A lot of times they are over cooked. The meatballs were not dry and you received a good amount of marinara for both. Pizza slice was big so you definitely got your money's worth. Also ordered fried ravioli not too much batter and aga ... read more
Lisa M. via yelp.com - Mar 13, 2022
I have this feeling that it doesn't matter what you order- you are going to savor EVERY BITE! We cam
I have this feeling that it doesn't matter what you order- you are going to savor EVERY BITE! We came thanks to a Yelp Elite event and ordered extra just because. They have a great beer selection- aka- John was happy with his Fat Tire pick. The garlic knots are some of the best I've ever had! I ordered a salad to go with all the carb ... read more
Crystal O. via yelp.com - Mar 11, 2022
What a menu! Whatever you crave it's here in a pizza form. Pickles and ranch maybe? They have it. Cr
What a menu! Whatever you crave it's here in a pizza form. Pickles and ranch maybe? They have it. Crust choices include cauliflower, thin or New York. Maybe your favorite toppings include, Feta or Ricotta with Grilled Chicken maybe? Steak or Meatballs? Even Eggplant it's avaliable here on freshly made crust of choice so enjoy some gr ... read more
Debbie F. via yelp.com - Mar 9, 2022
Best food in town ... read more
Gary Lee Stanley Your Sales Guy via google.com - Mar 2, 2022
Very good food, nice atmosphere a little slow but very good experience. Will be back for sure!
Mary Parramore via google.com - Feb 28, 2022
I love the pizza and the wings are great also. I love right across the street and it is very convenient to order take out or Delivery. Staff is always friendly when I arrived and my order is always delivered with care.
Tasha Holland via google.com - Feb 25, 2022
Very good food, nice atmosphere a little slow but very good experience. Will be back for sure!
Mary Crawley via google.com - Feb 21, 2022
What a wonderful surprise! Highly recommend. Delicious soft n gooey garlic knots n exquisite calzones! Oh and don't for get the fried raviolis!
E Colon via google.com - Feb 18, 2022
Well my return visit was 100 % better! Since this is within walking distance ,we go through often fo
Well my return visit was 100 % better! Since this is within walking distance ,we go through often for the pizza and calzones.
Andrew M. via yelp.com - Feb 13, 2022
My wife, nephew and I dropped by on a Friday evening around 630pm and although busy had no problem g
My wife, nephew and I dropped by on a Friday evening around 630pm and although busy had no problem getting a table. We looked over their beer list on the wall and found a couple of favorites. Our server promptly took our order and when we mentioned it was our first time enthusiastically suggested bread knots to start. Good thing to a ... read more
Michael K. via yelp.com - Feb 12, 2022
Great staff, good pizza.
David Kosa via google.com - Feb 11, 2022
It was a long way to travel but WORTH EVERY MINUTE!! We had fried pickles & naked garlic wings to start with & Ethan our server suggested to garlic knots ( OMG-DELECTABLE!! Then we ordered the Supreme pizza for dinner ., WORDS are not enough to describe the food, service & quality!! Thank you - NYC pizzeria & Thank you V4VICTORY for ... read more
Grace Wyman via google.com - Feb 11, 2022
Yummmmy this place was awesome food and it was delicious a definite a place to try people are very f
Yummmmy this place was awesome food and it was delicious a definite a place to try people are very friendly and on point cooks know what they are doing....the only little tiny tiny thing is that they should put cushion on the bench seats ....but besides that its was a definitely a 10+++...
Jose H. via yelp.com - Feb 1, 2022
Great pizza and salad. The cheesecake looks good too but I'm too full to eat it yet. This isn't in m
Great pizza and salad. The cheesecake looks good too but I'm too full to eat it yet. This isn't in my normal part of town but the pie is good enough to drive back this way for. Pretty unassuming location on the outside but a cool looking bar/pizzeria layout inside. Well done guys!
Jesse A. via yelp.com - Jan 30, 2022
Pizza is excellent! I've ordered here multiple times and it's some of the best pizza I've had. Get t
Pizza is excellent! I've ordered here multiple times and it's some of the best pizza I've had. Get the garlic knots with whatever you order. Definitely the best pizza place in Oakleaf. Only issue is the hours posted aren't always correct so best to call before trying to order.
Pete J. via yelp.com - Jan 28, 2022
Great pizza and the best wings! Great every time.
Great pizza and the best wings! Great every time.
Doug Johnson via facebook.com - Jan 26, 2022
They have won my heart (and stomach)!! Years ago, when they first opened I had issue upon issue with
They have won my heart (and stomach)!! Years ago, when they first opened I had issue upon issue with poor service, messed up orders, and poor quality food. After 3 tries, I gave up. When I heard there was a new owner, I decided to give it another go!!! I am a big fan of supporting small business! I'm so glad I did!!! The flavor - wow ... read more
Heather S. via yelp.com - Jan 25, 2022
A++
Good meal and exceptional service. Caleb, our server, was extremely personal and enhanced our dining experience with his friendly smile.
ilv2trvl2 via tripadvisor.com - Jan 15, 2022
Great pizza and wings. Staff was super nice and helpful.
Bob Ward via google.com - Jan 10, 2022
Excellent!! Best Veggie Pizza ever!
C Wten via google.com - Jan 3, 2022
My server was awesome! This time, I got the Pepperoni and Sausage Stromboli and it was great! I highly recommend it, as well as, the garlic knots!
T. Gerard Robinson via google.com - Jan 2, 2022
Great pizza with great service!
andyisarobot 3 via google.com - Dec 5, 2021
Local neighborhood pizza spot! If its wrong they fix it! The pizza is great! I love the ease of use
Local neighborhood pizza spot! If its wrong they fix it! The pizza is great! I love the ease of use on the app!
Jessica J. via yelp.com - Dec 5, 2021
I really like this places pizza and wings. Their breaded sweet thai chili wings are really good. How
I really like this places pizza and wings. Their breaded sweet thai chili wings are really good. However, I do have a couple of complaints. Every time I call it is hard to get them to take my order in a timely manner. For today's order, the left a topping off of my pizza after I waited close to an hour and a half for a delivery.
Brad H. via yelp.com - Dec 4, 2021
Best Pizza in Oakleaf ... read more
Chris B via google.com - Nov 12, 2021
Ordered half pepperoni half pineapple and pepperoni pizza it was sooo delicious!! Great service, great atmosphere will definitely come again!!
TARA Coston via google.com - Nov 12, 2021
Best cauliflower pizza in Jacksonville!
Will Petrelli via google.com - Nov 7, 2021
Ordered a few times now and the pizza and garlic knots are fantastic. Recommend ordering extra cheese because it can be pretty light on the cheese compared to other places. My kids love cheese pizzas from here. No delivery even though I live in the same neighborhood kind of stinks but it's worth picking it up. Way better than regular ... read more
Steven Anderson via google.com - Nov 5, 2021
First time getting food since the newest owner. Wings were huge, cooked perfect and were done right on time. Friendly staff.
Art Pimental via google.com - Oct 20, 2021
We got the pickle pizza, fried ravioli and 2 different kinds of wings. The food was absolutely amazing and our waiter was great. He was super busy, but got us everything we needed and was on top of it. Thanks for an awesome dining experience.
viperdog92 via google.com - Oct 9, 2021
Great pizza ... read more
Maryanne Markowski via google.com - Oct 3, 2021
First time going here was last Sunday and man I've been missing out. Garlic knots were out of the park, their cajun ranch wings were somehow the best wings I've ever had and coming from a pizza place? Shocker! And then the pizza.... that was great too. Classic ny style and the crust was crispy. Not to mention everything was fresh and ... read more
Logan S via google.com - Sep 29, 2021
We've been here before for pizza and wings, which were good. Tonight was chicken parmesan and eggplant parmesan and WOW both were great.
Christopher Billings via google.com - Sep 11, 2021
Garlic knots are great.
Roy via google.com - Sep 1, 2021
Great food, staff needs help with customer service ... read more
john belcher via google.com - Aug 31, 2021
Stromboli, calzone, and lasagna is top-notch! Definitely worth going a bit out of your way.
Stromboli, calzone, and lasagna is top-notch! Definitely worth going a bit out of your way.
Susan H. via yelp.com - Aug 16, 2021
I really like this place. Ethan the server is awesome!!! Pizza is good, wings are good, and so is th
I really like this place. Ethan the server is awesome!!! Pizza is good, wings are good, and so is the fried ravioli. If they offered a full bar... I'd give 5 stars!!! I'll always revisit ... read more
Cee L. via yelp.com - Aug 14, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire